HomeMy WebLinkAbout2010-10-27-LEARY-min Meeting Notes
AD HOC LEARY PROPERTY COMMUNITY HOUSING TASK FORCE
October 27, 2010, 8 30 a.m.
Room 207,Town Office Building
Present: Bob Bicknell, George Burnell, Marilyn Fenollosa, Bill Hays, Stephen Keane,Aaron
Henry,Wendy Manz, Deb Mauger, Maryann McCall-Taylor, Lester Savage, and Betsey Weiss
Ross Speer of Davis Square Architects
Minutes
Minutes of October 13, 2010 approved.
Concept Plans
The additional sketches were not yet available. Bob Bicknell said he would ask
Sasaki for their rough model of the site.
Site Program
Bill Hays spoke on behalf of LexHAB to say that they feel the site should have no
more than four units. He advised that it does not pay to over pitch at the beginning and
then reduce numbers. He felt that anything more than four,is more than the Board of
Selectmen or Town Meeting will support. The new construction in a barn motif,rather than
the usual LexHAB raised ranch is a good idea, They would like to go as green as possible
including the use of solar,recognizing that this may raise the construction costs but aim for
no more than a 50%increase in cost.
The Nantucket Housing Trust built two new green buildings for affordable housing.
One was spray foam and stick construction,while the other was poured concrete. The
exterior met design standards. The units were built within the contingency budget of a
conventional build.
Ross Spears said that green added 4%to a project he was familiar with but expect it
to be more in a smaller project.
Bill Hays wanted to take up the subject of the farm house. He does not feel it is a
good investment for the town. It will be a replica more than anything else. No matter the
source of funds,rehab is not appropriate.
Wendy Manz said that the CPC is looking at an annual appropriation for ready
money for housing. If established,a project would go back to the CPC but not have to go to
Town Meeting.
Betsey Weiss said she hopes for higher density,six or more units. She wants to
work toward a committee recommendation,not have one from the committee and one from
LexHAB. Ross Speer recommended six units as a better scale for a barn-like structure. Once
there is a commitment to four units,don't expect neighbors to support more.
Bob Bicknell said that the new construction will hold down the rehab costs due to
efficiencies of development. Bill Hays said it is wrong to mix the rehab costs with the new
construction. While efficiencies are fine,the rehab unit needs to stand on its own.
Betsey Weiss said it should not be assumed that the project is LexHAB's. Lexington
is also a member of Metro West Development Collaborative (MWDC) which is a very
knowledgeable entity and develops larger affordable housing projects that are more than
four units. In addition,the committee needs to speak to the neighbors first,before deciding
on anything.
Deb Mauger said they should take the time to do it right. There are competing
public interests,and priorities need to be set. She was concerned about what would be
found when trying to rehab. It might be better to rebuild a beautiful structure than try to
preserve what is there. Marilyn Fenollosa cautioned against going down the beauty route. It
isn't a historic preservation value. George Burnell said that no one outside of the room feels
there is anything to preserve. If historic preservation is pushed,it may lose votes.
Bob Bicknell said it is the Task Force's role to recommend to the Board of Selectmen.
What should the group do next?The Salemi report is all the Board of Selectmen have seen
and that seemed to say that the building can barely stand. There was further discussion of
the cost of rehabbing the farm house,and how the costs should be determined. Should
more funds be sought to explore rehab? In the end the group felt that they should keep
options open and ask the CPC to fund stabilizing the farm house and pre-development
studies.
CPC Application
Any application to the Community Preservation Committee (CPC) for funds is
subject to the Board of Selectmen's approval. Mr Burnell said it would also be an
opportunity to get feedback on the preservation of the farm house and the density of
development. Les Savage said he would go to the Board of Selectmen with the CPC
application for stabilization and pre-development funds,as been agreed to at the last
meeting. He was urged to keep his comments very general so neighbors would not feel that
decisions had been made without their input.
Public Meeting
There will be a neighborhood meeting on Tuesday, November 16 at 7 30 p.m.
Location to be determined.
The meeting was adjourned at 10 30
Next meeting•Wednesday, November 3 at 8 30 a.m., Room 207 Town Office Building