HomeMy WebLinkAbout2021-11-08-AC-STM-rpt RECEIVED
2021 01 IIMov, 1132 airy°m
TOWN CLERK
LEXINGTON MA
APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE
TOWN OF LEXINGTON
milli q
Ing
" s cc
APRIL 191"
REPORT TO THE
2021 - 1 SPECIAL TOWN MEETING
RELEASED NOVEMBER 1,2021
APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE MEMBERS
Glenn P. Parker, Chair• Sanjay Padaki, Vice Chair• Alan M. Levine, Secretary
Carolyn Kosnoff(ex officio; non-voting) • Anil A. Ahuja• John Bartenstein
Eric Michelson • Meg Muckenhoupt• Lily Marl Yan
2021-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
Contents
Summary of Warrant Article Recommendations .................................................................................ii
Preface.......................................................................................................................................................1
Introduction..............................................................................................................................................2
Warrant Article Analysis and Recommendations.................................................................................3
Article 2 Appropriate for Prior Years' Unpaid Bills.............................................................................3
Article 3 Establish, Dissolve and Appropriate To and From Specified Stabilization Funds................3
Article 4 Amend FY2022 Operating and Enterprise Budgets...............................................................4
Article 5 Appropriate for Police Station Architectural Design and Swing Space Construction...........6
Article 6 Appropriate for Community Preservation Projects................................................................7
Article 7 Appropriate for Westview Cemetery Building Construction.................................................9
Article 8 Climate Action Plan.............................................................................................................10
i
2021-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
Summary of Warrant Article Recommendations
Abbreviations
EF Enterprise Fund CPA Community Preservation Act
GF General Fund DSSF Debt Service Stabilization Fund
RE Retained Earnings IP A motion to Indefinitely Postpone is expected
RF Revolving Fund TDM Traffic Demand Management
Art- Funds Funding Committee
icle Title Requested Source Recommendation
2 Appropriate for Prior Years'Unpaid None N/A IP
Bills
3 Establish,Dissolve and Appropriate To $200,000 GF Approve (8-0)
and From Specified Stabilization Funds $570,300
4 Amend FY2022 Operating and Enter- See below See below Approve (8-0)
prise Budgets
Appropriate for Police Station Architec-
5 tural Design and Swing Space Construc- $870,000 GF Approve (8-0)
tion
Appropriate for Community Preserva- $75,000
6 tion Projects $235,750 CPA Approve (8-0)
$310,750
7 Appropriate for Westview Cemetery $770,000 Tax Levy Approve (8-0)
Building Construction
8 Climate Action Plan None N/A IP
ii
2021-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
Preface
This preface describes the structure and stylistic conventions used in this report. It is followed by an intro-
duction discussing changes in the Town's financial status since the 2021 Annual Town Meeting,along with
issues pertinent to the Town's general financial situation. The main body of this report contains article-by-
article discussions and recommendations on those articles that, in our opinion, have substantial financial
relevance.
The discussion for each article presents the prevailing view of the Committee, as well as any other consid-
erations or cautions that we feel Town Meeting should be informed of If one or more Committee members
are strongly opposed to the majority position,we summarize the opposing perspective. Each article discus-
sion concludes with the most recent vote of the Committee prior to publication. The vote is summarized by
the number of members in favor,followed by the number of members opposed,and lastly(when applicable)
the number of members abstaining, e.g., "(6-2-1)" indicates six members in favor, two opposed, and one
abstaining. It is not always possible to collect a complete vote for every article from nine voting members.
In such instances,the total number of votes and abstentions published will be less than nine. For conven-
ience, Committee votes are also summarized on the preceding pages.
This report does not replicate information readily available to Town Meeting members elsewhere. Key
documents that inform our analysis and provide a more thorough picture of the Town finances are:
• The Town Manager's Fiscal Year 2022 Recommended Budget & Financing Plan (the "Brown
Book"),dated February 22,2021,fully describes the annual budget of the Town. The Brown Book
also summarizes budget laws and bylaws (Appendix B) and includes a glossary of financial terms
(Appendix D).
• The Level Service and Recommended Budget of the Superintendent ofSchools,as presented January
5, 2021 (hereafter the "LPS Budget Book",which details the budget plan for the Lexington Public
Schools.
• Capital Expenditures Committee (CEC)Report to the 2021 Annual Town Meeting,which provides
recommendations on appropriation requests for capital projects.
• Community Preservation Committee (CPC) Report to the 2021 Annual Town Meeting,which de-
tails requests approved by the CPC and funded using revenue from the CPA surcharge.
The LPS Budget Book is available online at:
https://sites.google.com/lexingtonma.org/Ips-finance-and-operations/fy-22-budget
All other reports for this Town Meeting will be available online at:
https://www.lexingtonma.gov/town-meeting/pages/special-town-meeting-2021-1
Acknowledgements
The content of this report,except where otherwise noted,was researched,written and edited by Committee
members who volunteer their time and expertise,and with the support of Town staff.We have the pleasure
and the privilege of working with Town Manager James Malloy; Assistant Town Manager for Finance
Carolyn Kosnoff(an ex officio member of our Committee); Budget Officer Jennifer Hewitt; the Capital
Expenditures Committee;the Community Preservation Committee;the School Committee;the Permanent
Building Committee;the Planning Board; Superintendent of Schools Dr. Julie Hackett;Assistant Superin-
tendent for Finance and Operations David Coelho;and the Lexington Select Board.We thank the municipal
and school staff, Town officials,boards and volunteers who have contributed time and expertise to help us
prepare this report. Last but not least,we thank Sara Arnold,who records and prepares the minutes for our
meetings.
1
2.02.1-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
Introduction
The Appropriation Committee reports on the Town's annual budget as adopted by the Select Board,and on
subsequent changes and additions to the budget.including an assessment of the budget plan and a projection
for future years' revenues and expenses. This report includes the Committee's analysis and recommenda-
tions regarding all anticipated appropriations of Town funds, and other municipal matters that may come
before Town Meeting.This report is distributed as an electronic document via the Town website.The Com-
mittee also makes presentations during Town Meeting, including recommendations on appropriations and
other matters for which the Committee's formal position was pending at the time of publication.
The Committee's goal is to publish its report at least one week prior to the start of each town meeting,with
the understanding that financial articles could be taken up on the first night of the town meeting.
Committee Membership
Anil A. Ahuia was appointed to the committee shortly before the start of the 2021 Annual Town Meeting.
Due to the timing, he could not contribute to our report for the Annual Town Meeting, but he is now part
of the team. With one vacant seat,the Committee presently has eight voting members.
Vineeta Kumar was appointed to the committee at the same time,but unfortunately,she was unable to serve
due to a conflict with the Town Meeting Member Association's bylaws for its Executive Committee.
Reserve Fund
As of publication,the Committee has not been asked to approve any Reserve Fund transfers during FY2022,
and the balance in the Fund remains at$750,000. As always, any remaining funds will revert to Free Cash
at the end of the fiscal year.
Developments Since Adoption of the FY2022 Budget
The Town has begun to support staff working in offices, and to provide in-person services at the Town
Office Building. The Committee has chosen to continue meeting virtually via Zoom.
New Growth
The Assistant Town Manager for Finance reports that the Town's "new growth" revenue is now projected
to be just under $5 million, approximately $2.25 million more than the $2.75 million originally budgeted
for FY2022. This is a direct result of continuing robust development of both commercial and residential
real estate. Given the inherent volatility of the real estate sector of the economy,the Town uses a conserva-
tive estimate for new growth to limit any potential revenue shortfall in the budget.
The Town treats excess funds from new growth as one-time revenue during the current fiscal year, but in
subsequent years they are incorporated into the base tax levy. Assuming that the state Department of Rev-
enue certifies our FY2022 new growth figure prior to the start of the 2021-1 Special Town Meeting, the
money will be available for appropriation by Town Meeting.
Itis proposed that most of this additional revenue be appropriated for capital projects under Article 5 (Police
Station) and Article 7 (Westview Cemetery),with the remaining balance going to the Capital Stabilization
Fund under Article 3.
Updates
This report presents the official positions of the Committee as of the date of publication. The Committee
will continue to meet as necessary prior to and during Town Meeting and may revise its official positions
based on new or updated information. In a typical year,the Committee also reports orally to Town Meeting
on each article.The oral report summarizes the Committee's current position,which may have been updated
following publication of this report.
2
2021-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
Warrant Article Analysis and Recommendations
Article 2
Appropriate for Prior Years' Unpaid Bills
Funds Requested Funding Source Committee Recommendation
None N/A IP
As of this report's publication,the Town was not aware of any unpaid bills from prior years.
The Committee supports indefinite postponement.
Article 3
Establish, Dissolve and Appropriate To and From Specified
Stabilization Funds
Funds Requested Funding Source Committee Recommendation
TDM/PT SF $200,000
Capital SF $570,300 GF Approve (8-0)
This article requests the appropriation of funds into the Transportation Demand Management/Public Trans-
portation Stabilization Fund(TDM/PT) Stabilization Fund (SF) and the Capital SF.
Transportation Demand Management/Public Transportation SF
From time to time, a developer seeking a zoning change will sign a memorandum of understanding(MoU)
with the Town that requires one-time or recurring contributions to the Town to be used in ways that reduce
automobile trips by their employees or customers.
In the past, these funds were accumulated in a special revenue fund, and Town Meeting was routinely
required to appropriate them into the Transportation Demand Management/Public Transportation Stabili-
zation Fund. At the 2020-3 Special Town Meeting, Town Meeting voted under Article 3 to allow funds
received under certain agreements to be deposited directly into the TDM/PT SF without appropriation.
Payments have been received from Takeda Pharmaceuticals ($124,113), Avalon at Lexington Hills
($46,286), Watertown Savings Bank ($8,674), and Lexington Place ($4,775) for a total of$183,848. Per
the previous vote of Town Meeting,these funds were transferred directly into the TDM/PT SF. The current
balance (late October 202 1)in the TDM/PT SF is $891,846,which includes the payments listed here.
In addition,the Town recently received a$200,000 grant from the Massachusetts Department of Transpor-
tation (Mass DOT) to support public transportation. The grant is being applied to the FY2022 Lexpress
budget(see Article 4, below). In keeping with the spirit of the grant,this article requests an appropriation
of the$200,000 in tax levy funds freed up from the Lexpress budget into the TDM/PT SF to help fund other
town transportation needs.
Capital SF
The Capital SF was established as a repository of funds to supplement debt service payments on future
capital projects.Two major capital projects,namely the replacement of the Police Station and the renovation
or replacement of Lexington High School, are on the horizon. Construction of the Police Station is likely
3
2.02.1-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
to commence within a few years, while the Lexington High School project may begin within five to ten
years.Whether the High School is eventually renovated or replaced,the total cost will almost certainly far
surpass any prior capital project in the Town. It is desirable to grow the Capital SF in advance of the sharp
rises in debt service that will follow immediately after bonds are issued to fund a high school project.
The requested appropriation into the CSF would transfer$570,300 from the balance of"new growth"rev-
enue,which is property tax revenue in excess of the estimate approved for the FY2022 budget.
A small part of this new growth, about $57,000, can be traced to the recent PSDUP-based developments
that are currently under construction at 186 Bedford St. and on Watertown St. (Waterstone and Bridges).
This is only the preliminary new growth amount for these two partially completed projects. The final new
growth revenue will be larger once they are completed. Another PSDUP-based development at 1050 Wal-
tham St. is also expected to generate significant new growth in the coming fiscal year(s).
This appropriation into the Capital SF is consistent with a process recently recommended by the Town
Manager's Financial Working Group to earmark a portion of current and future revenue from two compo-
nents of new growth for the Capital SF: (1) that from properties developed under the framework of the
rezoning/PSDUP process; and (2) that from properties developed under the recently approved zoning
changes for the Hartwell Innovation Park (C-HIP, see Art. 45 from the 2021 ATM). The purpose of this
earmark is to establish a reliable and growing source of recurring revenue from the tax levy to support the
Capital SF,which has heretofore been funded exclusively with one-time funding sources.
The balance in the Capital SF on September 30, 2021, was $21,096,702. This balance reflects transfers
approved at the 2021 ATM.
It should be noted that this fund is already being used to mitigate the impact of debt service on existing
exempt capital projects and selected non-exempt capital projects. Therefore, not all of the present balance
will be available to offset costs of the police station and high school projects.
The Committee recommends approval by a vote of(8-0).
Article 4
Amend FY2022 Operating and Enterprise Budgets
Funds Requested Funding Source Committee Recommendation
See below See below Approve(8-0)
At last spring's Annual Town Meeting,operating and enterprise fund budgets were presented and approved
based on the FY2022 Recommended Budget and Financing Plan published on February 22, 2021. This
article proposes several modest adjustments to those budgets in view of developments which have occurred
since that time. Line numbers in the tables for this section refer to budget categories in the Plan. Proposed
changes to the FY2022 Community Preservation Fund budget are addressed in Article 6.
Operating Budget
Town staff is proposing both increases and decreases in the FY2022 operating budget, resulting in a net
reduction of$180,870. The details of, and reasons for,the changes are set forth below.
Line From To Change
2140 Unemployment $ 300,000 $200,000 $ (100,000)
The Town's unemployment costs experienced year-to-date have been lower than anticipated, largely be-
cause there have been minimal COVID-related claims and payments. Town staff thus proposes to reduce
4
2021-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
the unemployment line item by one-third, to $200,000, which should be sufficient to cover costs through
the end of the fiscal year.
Line From To Change
4100 Law Enforcement Personal Services $ 7,209,908 $ 7,118,998 $ (90,910)
With the transition underway to install Pay-by-Phone meters in the Depot Square parking lot, there is a
reduced need for parking lot attendants;this allows a modest reduction in the law enforcement budget.
Line From To Change
4200 Fire Personal Services $ 7,047,201 $ 7,247,201 $200,000
Due to a number of unanticipated personnel-related expenses incurred by the Fire Department in FY2021,
including a contract settlement which had an impact on overtime pay, approximately $190,000 in end-of-
year adjustments were required in July of 2021 to supplement the FY2021 budget.Because this higher than
anticipated trend of expenses is expected to continue into FY2022, it is proposed to increase the FY2022
budget by a similar amount.
Line From To Change
5100 Library Personal Services $ 2,475,402 $ 2,525,607 $ 50,205
8600 Innovation&Technology Personal $ 955,997 $ 932,679 $ (50,205)
Services
Following the onset of the pandemic, the Town Library has significantly increased its on-line operations.
Because the Town's Webmaster,whose costs have historically been in the Information Technology budget,
now spends most of his time on Library matters,it is proposed to transfer this expense from the Innovation
& Technology Personal Services budget to the Library Personal Services Budget. This is a housekeeping
matter that will result in no net change to the Town's overall budget.
Line From To Change
6000 Human Services Expenses $ 786,991 $ 586,991 $ (200,000)
Due to the receipt of unanticipated grant funding from MassDOT,the expense budget for Lexpress, a con-
tracted-for service, can be reduced by$200,000.Note that Article 3 proposes that the $200,000 in tax levy
funds thereby freed up be appropriated to the TDM/PT Stabilization Fund to help fund other town trans-
portation needs.
Line From To Change
8210-8220 Town Manager Personal Services $ 922,639 $ 932,679 $ 10,040
The Town Manager has identified the need for a professional management analyst to assist with the review
and analysis of a number of Town initiatives and other developments which have added substantially to the
responsibilities of his office over the last several years. These responsibilities include: financial analysis of
the use and disposition of the substantial federal funds the Town expects to receive under the American
Rescue Plan Act of 2021 (ARPA); preparation of periodic reports required under recently adopted afford-
able housing"linkage"articles;monitoring compliance with various Town Meeting resolutions to consider
matters of sustainability,inclusion and other matters in the Town's day-to-day operations; and other budg-
etary and financial issues which would benefit from professional analysis.
A plan to include such a position in the original FY2022 budget was deferred due to continued concern
about potential unanticipated costs resulting from the Covid-19 pandemic. However, with those concerns
allayed,the needs for analysis now more urgent,and the availability of still unallocated municipal funds as
well as ARPA funding to help defray the cost,the time is opportune to create and fund this position. The
5
2.02.1-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
Town has had, and will continue to have,the benefit of a short-term management intern under its existing
management training program.
The ultimate annual salary range targeted for the proposed new analyst position, which is expected to be
ongoing and therefore can be viewed as a program improvement request,is in the range of$60,000-90,000,
net of benefits. The funding now sought under Article 4 is substantially less than that because it is only for
the remaining half of FY2022 and it is expected that much of the cost, at least in the short run, will be
covered by ARPA funds: 75%in FY2022; 50%in FY2023; and 25%in FY2024.
Water/Wastewater Enterprise Funds
Two categories of adjustments are proposed for the water and wastewater enterprise funds:
Line From To Change
3610 Water Department Personal Services $ 903,535 $ 865,454 $ (38,081)
3710 Wastewater Department Personal Services $401,775 $ 389,779 $ (11,996)
Because there was an inadvertent duplication of certain expenses resulting from the recent public works
union contract settlement,the water and wastewater budgets may be reduced as indicated above.
Line From To Change
3620 MWRA Water Assessment $ 8,782,170 $ 8,743,912 $ (38,258)
3720 MWRA Wastewater Assessment $ 8,232,301 8,177,213 $ (55,088)
The amounts appropriated under Article 5 of the 2021 Annual Town Meeting for Water and Wastewater
Enterprise Fund expenses were based on preliminary FY2022 assessments issued by the MWRA in Febru-
ary. The revisions here reflect the final assessments approved by the MWRA board this past June. These
revised assessments,which slightly lower the costs of each fund,were used in the calculation of the FY2022
water and wastewater rates approved by the Selectmen earlier this fall. Amending the original appropria-
tions is a simple housekeeping task.
The Committee recommends approval by a vote of(8-0).
Article 5
Appropriate for Police Station Architectural Design and Swing
Space Construction
Funds Requested Funding Source Committee Recommendation
$870,000 GF Approve(8-0)
This article requests the appropriation of$870,000 using newly available tax levy funds resulting from the
recognition of new growth revenue to fund: (1) $254,315 in additional architectural design work for a new
police station; and (2) $614,100 in construction funds to convert 173 Bedford St. to a temporary police
station.
Under Article 14 of the 2018 Annual Town Meeting,$1,862,622 was appropriated for design and engineer-
ing costs for a proposed new Police Station at the current Massachusetts Avenue site. The existing police
station, which opened in 1956, lacks many basic amenities of a modern police facility. At the time of that
vote, it was envisioned that a request would be made for the appropriation of construction funds late in
2019 or in 2020. However,in view of the nationwide discussion of police and policing which followed the
death of George Floyd in Minneapolis in May of 2020, the Select Board decided to pause the project and
6
2021-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
to initiate a community conversation on policing and the needs of the proposed Police Station. With that
process now completed,the Select Board is ready to proceed with the project, incorporating recommenda-
tions resulting from the outreach into the design of the new station.
At the Select Board's request, the architect provided two new design alternatives. Option A incorporated
limited changes to the existing design without enlarging the building. Option B included more extensive
modifications from the existing design, including a larger building, in response to suggestions from the
community conversations. The Select Board recently voted to support Option B, with an estimated con-
struction cost of$32.8 million,which is approximately 10 percent more than the cost for Option A.
A supplemental appropriation of$254,315 is now sought to cover additional architectural fees due to:
1. The Select Board's request for two new Schematic Design alternatives
2. A decision to integrate solar panels into the design
3. The need for post-construction restoration of Fletcher Park
4. Additional design changes based on community feedback.
The remaining $614,100 of the appropriation would fund the construction costs to convert 173 Bedford
Street from its prior use as a temporary Fire Station to a temporary Police Station.All changes would be to
the building's interior, including securing the main entrance and adding a secure booking and interview
space, an evidence evaluation lab and storage facility, a dispatch center, and a communications equipment
area.
A detailed breakdown of all funds requested follows:
Police Station—Design and Construction Documents
Additional architect fees $254,315
Swing Space Renovation– 173 Bedford St
Construction/Renovation $375,000
Antennas/Radio communication equipment $123,000
Relocate the 911 Dispatch Center $50,000
Architect fees $41,100
Relocation costs $25,000
Total $868,415
The requested amount is rounded up to $870,000. It is anticipated that a request for the appropriation of
construction funds for the new Police Station will be made at the 2022 Annual Town Meeting,presumably
contingent on a debt exclusion referendum to be held later in the spring. If the funding is approved, con-
struction of the new Police Station could begin as early as the fall of 2022.
The Committee recommends approval by a vote of(8-0).
Article 6
Appropriate for Community Preservation Projects
Funds Requested Funding Source Committee Recommendation
$75,000
$235,750 CPA Approve(8-0)
$310,750
At the 2021 Annual Town Meeting a total of$2,684,550 was appropriated under the Community Preserva-
tion Act(CPA),primarily for debt service on previously approved land acquisitions and the renovation of
7
2.02.1-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
the Cary Memorial Building. Largely due to the pandemic,a relatively small number of new projects were
put forward last spring, leaving a substantial balance of unexpended CPA funds. This fall,the Community
Preservation Committee (CPC) is proposing two modest supplemental appropriations and one change in
scope related to the funding of projects approved in earlier years. Delaying these requests until next year's
Annual Town Meeting would potentially increase these projects' costs while leaving the Old Res bathhouse
unusable for an entire recreation season.
6(a) Park and Playmund Improvements Sutherland Park
An appropriation of$75,000 is requested to install an additional play structure for children ages 5-12 in
Sutherland Park,a 20-acre park at the end of Sutherland Road.A four-acre section of the park managed by
the Recreation and Community Programs Department features a Little League field, a basketball court,
swings, and a playground with equipment for children ages 2-5.
At the 2020 Annual Town Meeting, $95,000 was appropriated to rehabilitate the playground's existing
equipment. After the new play structure was purchased with those funds, members of the community in-
formed Town staff and the Select Board that the new equipment wasn't suitable for children over 5. The
CPC has approved a request by the Department of Recreation and Community Programs and the Recreation
Committee to fund the purchase of an additional structure suitable for older children. This issue is coming
before this Special Town Meeting instead of the next annual town meeting so that the new structure for
older children can be installed more quickly. This will help to ensure that both structures will come up for
replacement at roughly the same time—minimizing disruption for playground reconstruction in the future.
If funds are not allocated at this Special Town Meeting,the Recreation Committee will include this project
in its five-year capital planning for a future year,delaying the installation of the equipment and causing the
two structures to be out of phase for future replacement. There will be more disruption, expenses, and
unhappy children if the playground needs to be closed twice to replace equipment.
The proponents expect to engage the neighborhood in planning for the new structure this winter and install
the new structure in spring 2022. The expected life cycle for these play structures is 15 years.
6(b)Parker Meadow Accessible Trail Construction Supplemental Funds
This is a request for $235,750 to supplement a previous appropriation for construction of the Parker
Meadow Accessible Trail. This trail will provide barrier-free access to Parker Meadow, a 17-acre property
located near Lexington Center with direct access to the Minuteman Bikeway,via a passive recreational trail
system for members of the public with physical, vision and auditory limitations. This is a collaborative
project involving private citizens,land stewards,the Conservation Commission,the Recreation Committee,
and the Commission on Disability.
The funds now requested would be in addition to $585,526 previously appropriated for this project in
FY2015 ($34,500,design and engineering)and FY2021 (construction,$551,026).If the supplemental fund-
ing is approved,the total funding for this trail will be $786,776.
When the trail construction was put out to bid this year,the lowest bid exceeded the construction appropri-
ation by more than $205,000. The proponents attribute the increase to increased demand for construction
projects and higher costs of construction materials such as lumber for the boardwalk. Construction costs
are expected to continue to increase, so further delays could make this project even more expensive.
Article 6(c) Old Reservoir Bathhouse Construction
This item does not request the appropriation of any new funds. It is on the warrant because the CPC needs
Town Meeting approval for a change in construction plans for the Old Reservoir Bathhouse.
Town Meeting appropriated$620,000 at the 2019 Annual Town Meeting to repair the Old Reservoir Bath-
house, including funding for plumbing repairs, installation of new fixtures and a new roof, and ADA im-
provements throughout the bathhouse and site. As with the Parker Meadow Accessible Trail, bids for this
8
2021-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
work came in substantially above the appropriation. Instead of seeking supplemental funding,the Depart-
ment of Recreation and Community Programs has concluded that installing a new,pre-cast concrete build-
ing would be more cost-effective than renovating the existing bathhouse. This modification would bring
the project within the previously appropriated budget, so no new funds are needed.
The Committee recommends approval by a vote of(8-0).
Article 7
Appropriate for Westview Cemetery Building Construction
Funds Requested Funding Source Committee Recommendation
$770,000 Tax Levy Approve(8-0)
This article requests a supplemental appropriation for the construction of a new office and equipment
maintenance building on the Westview Cemetery grounds, including the costs of demolition,architectural,
and engineering services, original equipment, furnishings, landscaping, paving and other site and traffic
improvements incidental or related to such construction.Westview Cemetery is the Town's active cemetery
with an average of two hundred burials per year.
History
At the 2015 Annual Town Meeting, $35,000 was appropriated to hire an architect to assess the current
building, and to determine if the existing building can be renovated and expanded, or if a new building is
needed. The assessment was performed by TBA Architects Inc., and at the 2017 Annual Town Meeting,
$270,000 was appropriated to develop designs for the renovation of the existing building or for construction
of a new building. At the 2018 Annual Town Meeting an article to appropriate construction funds was
indefinitely postponed in order to consider citizen requests for the inclusion of a crematory facility as part
of the new building. The Ad-hoc Crematory Study Committee (CSC) was appointed by the Board of Se-
lectmen in fall 2018. The committee made a recommendation, subsequently accepted by the Board of Se-
lectmen, that required the design of the new Westview Cemetery building to be able to accommodate the
addition of a crematory at a future date. At the 2020 Annual Town Meeting, $3,290,000 was appropriated
for construction of the building with the new design.
Current status
Town staff vetted the design of the building with the Permanent Building Committee and subsequently
issued a bid package in June 2021.Five bids were received,and all are substantially above the appropriated
funding. The Covid-19 pandemic has impacted supply chains and also worker availability resulting in
higher costs of construction. Based on these bids, a supplemental appropriation of$770,000 is requested
bringing the total budget for this project to$4,060,000. If the appropriation is approved,a new bid package
will be issued in early 2022.
Financing Plan
The Westview Cemetery building is expected to cost approximately $4.06 million with a 20-year bond
duration for any debt.The current request for supplemental appropriation of$770,000 will be cash financed
from the projected surplus new growth, as indicated in the introduction. The originally budgeted construc-
tion cost of$3,290,000 will be debt-financed with a level-payment amortization schedule at an assumed
interest rate of 4%. The debt service would be funded in part using fee revenue from the General Fund and
the Sale of Cemetery Lots Fund. The latter had a fund balance of$681,236 at the end of FY2021 and
receives ongoing revenue from sales of cemetery lots and burials. This funding model anticipates the need
for supplements from the tax levy to cover debt service from FY2028 through FY2043. The total tax levy
9
2021-1 STM APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE I NOVEMBER 2021
supplement needed to cover the debt service is projected to be approximately 25%of the total project cost,
or$1.5 million over the life of the debt.
Cemetery Operating Revenues and Expenses
When a grave is sold,45%of the revenue is directed to the Sale of Cemetery Lots Fund,and the other 55%
is transferred to the Cemetery Perpetual Care Trust account which is managed by the Trustees of the Public
Trust. When a burial is performed, the fee revenue is directed to the General Fund. This General Fund
revenue supports cemetery operations, including staff costs and operating expenses. In addition, interest
earned from the Cemetery Perpetual Care Trust Fund is transferred to the General Fund annually to support
cemetery operations.
These two funding sources do not fully cover the Town's cemetery operations, so the tax levy makes up
the difference. Municipalities are directed by law to provide cemeteries and burial services, so it is not
unusual that the tax levy would partially fund cemetery operations. The history of tax levy support to the
cemetery operations from FY2015 to FY2021 is shown below.
FY2021 FY2020 FY2019 FY2018 FY2017 FY2016 FY2015
Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual Actual
Cemetery Fee Revenue $164,198 $182,405 $198,293 $162,270 $123,190 $125,588 $133,079
(General Fund)
Interest Income from $72,925 $90,038 $50,000 $48,500 $105,000 $105,000 $105,000
Cemetery Annual Care*
Total Cemetery Revenue $237,123 $272,443 $248,293 $210,770 $228,190 $230,588 $238,079
Cemetery Operations Salaries $283,644 $248,335 $230,705 $238,714 $248,370 $241,225 $221,437
&Wages
Cemetery Operating Expenses $60,018 $43,538 $67,008 $64,201 $61,800 $75,114 $48,868
Total Cemetery Expenses $343,662 $291,873 $297,713 $302,914 $310,170 $316,339 $270,305
Tax Levy Support of $(106,539) $(19,430) $(49,240) $(92,144) $(81,980) $(85,751) $(32,226)
Cemetery Operations
*Interest Income values prior to FY2020,are budgeted amounts and not actuals
The Committee recommends approval by a vote of(8-0).
Article 8
Climate Action Plan
Funds Requested Funding Source Committee Recommendation
None N/A IP
No action is proposed under this article.
The Committee supports indefinite postponement.
10