HomeMy WebLinkAbout2014-06-16-SPTM-min June 16,2014 Special Town Meeting
Moderator Deborah Brown called to order the 2014 Special Town Meeting,Monday,June 16,
2014 at 7:30 p.m.,Margery M.Battin Hall,Cary Memorial Building;A quorum of 157 members
present.
Town Clerk Donna M.Hooper read the Special Town Meeting Warrant until waived. The Town
Clerk read the Constables Return of Service.
The Moderator reviewed the procedures for the hand-held voting units and welcomed Sarah
Nathan, newly elected Precinct 3 Town Meeting Member,elected by precinct members to fill
the recent vacancy.
ARTICLE 1: REPORTS OF COMMITTEES
7:40 p.m. Glenn Parker,pr.3,moved the report of the Appropriation Committee be received&
placed on file. Unanimously Adopted.
7:41 p.m. Jill Hai,pct.4,moved the report of the Capital Expenditures Committee be received
&placed on file. Unanimously Adopted
7:42 p.m. Marilyn Fenollosa,pr.5,moved the report of the Community Preservation
Committee be received&placed on file. Unanimously Adopted.
7:42 p.m. Charles Horning,pr.8,moved the report of the Planning Board be received&placed
on file. Unanimously Adopted. Mr.Hornig reported on the zoning articles and announced the
resignation of Board member Gregory Zurlo,effective June 17,2014.
7:50 p.m. Presented by Edmund Grant,pr.6. Mr. Grant reported he will recuse himself from
voting on articles 2- 4. Mr. Grant reviewed procedures to be followed by the proposed
developer, Artis Senior Living, and referenced the revised MOU in the evening's handouts.
Moderator Deborah Brown recognized Jay Hicks, Senior Vice President, Artis Senior
Living. Approved by Attorney
General Martha
7:52 p.m. Mr.Jay Hicks presented Posed July 22,2014.
ARTICLE 2: AMEND ZONING BYLAW—430 CONCORD AVENUE
MOTION: To amend the Code of the Town of Lexington Zoning By-Law Sections and
the Zoning Map of the Town of Lexington by changing the district designation of the
land described in a certain metes and bounds description and certain plans on file with the
Planning Board from the current RO One Family Dwelling District to a CD Planned
Commercial District with certain specified uses(pursuant to the provisions of Town of
Lexington Code 135-7)said property being commonly known as Town Assessors'Map
10,Parcel 8,430 Concord Avenue,and to allow construction of a new building on the
property of approximately 34,000 square feet together with parking and other
improvements to be known as Artis Senior Living,and to approve the"Preliminary Site
Development and Use Plan for the Planned Commercial District at 430 Concord Avenue,
Lexington,Massachusetts"(the"PSDUP")filed with the Lexington Town Clerk and
Planning Board April 24,2014,revised June 9,2014,and to approve standards for
development,uses permitted,dimensional standards and other provisions contained
within the PSDUP.
7:53 p.m. Mr.Hicks reviewed requested zoning and development,the background of the
Artis Senior Living corporation,and the particulars proposed in developing the site at 430
Concord Avenue as a memory care assisted living facility.
8:12 p.m. Charles Hornig moved the report of the Planning Board under Article 2 be
received and placed on file. Unanimously Adopted.
Mr.Hornig reported on Article 2,with support of the Planning Board,4 in favor, 1 opposed.
8:15 p.m. Selectman Deborah Manger reported the full support of Board of Selectmen.
8:19 P.M. Glenn Parker,reported full support of the Appropriation Committee.
8:20 p.m. Philip Hamilton,Conservation Commission,spoke on the Commission's support.
8:20 p.m. David Kessler,20 Barberry Rd,spoke in opposition.
8:24 p.m. Planning Board Chairman Charles Hornig responded to questions on property
frontage,sewer easement,and other possible property use.
8:27 p.m. Hank Manz,pr.9,spoke in favor of articles 2,3,4.
8:29 p.m. Robert Rotberg,pr.3,spoke in opposition.
8:32 p.m. MaryJo Bohart,Chamber of Commerce,spoke in support of the proposed facility.
8:33 p.m. Robert Harris,500 Concord Ave,spoke in opposition.
June 16, 2014 Special Town Meeting, cont....
8:36 p.m. Members questioned the public benefit and affordability aspects of the proposed
development and MOU. Charles Hornig explained the MOU agreement process and that the
Zoning Board of Appeals is not bound by the MOU. Selectman Deborah Manger explained the
MOU considers the facility residents would be non-drivers and anticipated low impact of
employee transportation on the area. Artis Senior Living representative Jay Hicks further
explained not providing affordable units within proposed project.
8:41 p.m. Nancy Adler,pr.1,Chair,Council on Aging,spoke on need of facility of this type
and urged town meeting to consider housing as proposed.
8:42 p.m. Members spoke in favor and opposition,identifying issues including Concord
Ave roadway widening,residential/commercial mix of the area,and process of CD rezoning.
8:46 p.m. Marina Thompson,500 Concord Ave,spoke on area's residential/commercial mix.
8:52 p.m. Charles Hornig responded to questions on proposed units,40B eligibility and,
permitted uses for the property,with or absent this requested rezoning.
8:55 p.m. Guy Weinzapfel,4 Stonewall Rd,spoke on residential zoning and other possible
proposals. Members spoke in opposition and support,questioned role of zoning within the town,
conditions at the property,and affordable units at the facility.
9:03 p.m. Cindy Lewis,5 Hampton Rd,confirmed property views from her property.
9:04 p.m. Selectman Deborah Manger reiterated authority of the town regarding affordable
units at this facility,and the negotiation with Artis Senior Living for an affordability trust fund.
9:07 p.m. Town Counsel Kevin Batt responded to questions on PSDUP amendments,and
timing requirements for submittal before town meeting convened and before any vote by town
meeting.
9:09 P.M. Members questioned specifics on the proposed medical care at facility,spoke in
support and opposition.
9:13 p.m. Sharon Cerny, 1 Barberry Rd.,spoke in opposition and in support of clustered
housing for adults with disabilities.
9:14 p.m. Jay Hicks,Artis Senior Living,responded to questions on affordability.
9:18 P.M. Members continued to speak in support and opposition to the motion,questioning
affordability. Mr.Hicks explained the$150,000 contribution.
9:27 p.m. Planning Board Chair Charles Hornig responded to questions of Eric Michelson,
pr.1,on by-right uses of this property and any likely mitigation. Mr.Hornig confirmed by-right
uses are exempt from the process of regulatory control.
9:30 p.m. Bruce Morgan,396 Concord Avenue,commented on property location and
development scale and positioning on the lot. Mr.Morgan questioned parking requirements and
control of parking along Concord Ave.
9:32 p.m. David Kanter,pr.7,called the question. Vote on calling the question on Article 2:
Yes No Abstain
133 18 6
9:35 p.m. Edmund Grant summarized requested action and benefits of the proposal.
9:37 p.m. Vote on Article 2
Yes No Abstain
114 38 5
Article 2 Declared adopted by more than the necessary two-thirds,with 114 in favor,38
opposed.
June 16, 2014 Special Town Meeting, cont....
9:40 p.m. Selectman Deborah Manger moved articles 3 and 4,to be discussed simultaneously.
ARTICLE 3: LAND ACQUISITION—OFF CONCORD AVENUE
MOTION: That the Conservation Commission be authorized to purchase or otherwise
acquire, and the Selectmen be authorized to take by eminent domain, upon the written
request of the Conservation Commission, for conservation purposes including outdoor
recreation as provided by Section 8C of Chapter 40 of the Massachusetts General Laws,
any fee, easement or other interests and convey a conservation restriction as defined in
Section 31 of Chapter 184 of the General Laws in all or any part of land shown as Lot 1
on Assessors' Property Map 6, now or formerly of John H. Sellars, that the sum of
$220,000 be appropriated for such land acquisition, and to meet this appropriation
$220,000 be appropriated from the Open Space Reserve of the Community Preservation
Fund.
ARTICLE 4: AUTHORIZE EASEMENT ON LAND AT 430 CONCORD AVENUE
MOTION: That the Board of Selectmen be authorized to acquire by eminent domain,
purchase or otherwise easements and expand the uses of the existing sewer easement on
property shown on Assessors'Property Map 10,Lots 7 and 8 to access the land shown on
Assessors'Property Map 6,Lot 1.
9:40 p.m. Ms.Manger presented explanation and position of the Board of Selectmen.
9:44 p.m. Philip Hamilton,Conservation Commission,explained Conservation issues,
jurisdiction,and value. The Conservation Commission supports Articles 3&4.
9:46 p.m. Jill Hai,reported unanimous support of the Capital Expenditures Committee
for Articles 3 and 4.
9:47 p.m. Glenn Parker reported unanimous support of the Appropriation Committee(7-0)
for articles 3 and 4.
9:47 p.m. Marilyn Fenollosa reported support of Community Preservation Committee for
Article 3,with 8 in favor,0 opposed,for$220,000 to be appropriated for article 3;
no position on Article 4.
9:48 p.m. Joel Adler,pr.1,spoke against article 3,addressing 2 appraisals and requested
amount.
9:49 p.m. David Kaufman,pr.6,questioned the Selectmen on property access. Selectman
Deborah Manger explained access defined broadly to be negotiated to include walking easement.
9:51 p.m. Vote on Article 4
Yes I No Abstain
147 14 2
Article 4 declared adopted by more than necessary two-thirds,with 147 in favor,4 opposed.
9:51 p.m. Vote on Article 3
Yes No Abstain
131 18 3
Article 3 declared adopted by more than necessary two-thirds,with 131 in favor, 18 opposed.
9:53 presented by Margaret Coppe,School Committee.
ARTICLE 5: SCHOOL MASTER PLAN
MOTION: That$250,000 be appropriated for a school building master plan,to be
Spent under the direction of the School Committee,and that to meet this appropriation
$250,000 be raised in the tax levy.
9:55 p.m. Superintendent Dr.Paul Ash reviewed the 2009 Master Plan for school infrastructure
and the basis for moving forward with school work for Bridge,Bowman and Estabrook schools.
Dr.Ash reviewed school enrollment increases,rapid in-migration,and need for a new master
plan and timeline. Dr.Ash reported anticipated fall 2014 completion,to result in requests to be
made to Town Meeting at that time.
10:01 P.M. Margaret Coppe reported unanimous support of School Committee.
10:02 p.m. Peter Kelley reported unanimous support of Board of Selectmen.
10:02 p.m. Jill Hai reported unanimous support of Capital Expenditures Committee.
10:03 p.m. Glenn Parker reported unanimous support of Appropriation Committee.
10:04 p.m. Jonathan Himmel,Permanent Building Committee,reported PBC participation in
master planning committee,for which Carl Oldenberg and Jonathan Himmel
have been selected for participation. Mr.Himmel reported such process can be
construed as support.
June 16, 2014 Special Town Meeting, cont....
10:04 p.m. Margaret Coppe responded to questions on the master planning process,
frequency,and census updates,including involvement of the Town Clerk's
Office. Dr.Ash responded to questions on anticipated expenditures of the
$250,000 and difference between 2009 master plan and areas requested to be
included in a new plan—including both architectural work for building suitability
to be informed by the citizen's committee methodology enrollment projections.
Dr.Ash and Public Facilities Director Patrick Goddard responded to questions on
the 2009 plan cost,staffing plans,resources to be allocated to this project,
schedule,scope,and deliverables.
10:16 p.m. Vote on Article 5
Yes No Abstain
136 13 14
10:18 P.M. Article 5 declared adopted.
10:17 p.m. Presented by Selectman Joseph Pato.
ARTICLE 6: AMEND GENERAL BYLAWS—CONTRACTS AND DEEDS
MOTION: That Section 32-4 of Chapter 32 of the Code of the Town of Lexington be
amended as set forth in the Article,and further that non-substantive changes to the
numbering of this bylaw be permitted in order that it be in compliance with the
numbering format of the Code of Lexington.
""""""""" Approved by Attorney General
Warrant Text: Martha Coakley July 9,2014.
Posted July 22,2014.
To see if the Town will vote to amend Section 32-4 of Chapter 32("Contracts
and Deeds")of the Code of
the Town of Lexington by deleting the following line from the Table entitled Type of Contract and
Number of Years:
Leases,licenses,power purchase agreements,agreements for payments in lieu of taxes(PILOTs),and/or 20
other agreements for the purpose of installing solar energy facilities and purchasing solar electrici
And replacing it with the following two lines:
Leases,licenses,power purchase agreements and/or other agreements for the purpose of installing solar 22
energy facilities and purchasing solar electricity
Agreements for payments in lieu of taxes(PILOTS)with owners of solar energy facilities on Town- 20
owned property
Or act in any other manner in relation thereto.
----------------------
Mr.Pato reviewed requested action and solar agreement impact on requested action.
Mr.Pato reported unanimous support of the Board of Selectmen.
Beth Masterman reported unanimous support of the Capital Expenditures Committee.
10:19 p.m. Glenn Parker reported unanimous support of the Appropriation Committee.
10:19 p.m. Vote on Article 6
Yes No Abstain
132 1 3
10:19 P.M. Article 6 declared adopted.
June 16, 2014 Special Town Meeting cont.... Approved by Attorney General
Martha Coakley July 9,2014.
10:20 p.m. Presented by Selectman Norman Cohen. Posted July 22,2014.
ARTICLE 7: AMEND GENERAL BYLAWS REGARDING
REPORTING PERIOD FOR TOWN COUNSEL'S ANNUAL REPORT
MOTION: That Section 90-28 of Chapter 90 of the Code of the Town of Lexington
("Annual Report"),be amended as set forth below,and further that non-substantive
changes to the numbering of this bylaw be permitted in order that it be in compliance
with the numbering format of said Code:
The Town Counsel shall annually report in writing to the Board of Selectmen,by a date
determined by the Board of Selectmen,all actions by or against the Town which were
pending at the beginning of the preceding fiscal year;all actions brought by or against the
Town during such year;and all actions settled or disposed of during such year. Such
report shall show the full name of each plaintiff or defendant,the nature and amount of
the claim in each case,and the terms upon which any case was settled or disposed of
during such year. Such report shall be printed in the Annual Town Report.
Mr. Cohen reported unanimous support of the Selectmen.
10:21 p.m. Vote on Article 7
Yes No Abstain
135 0 3
10:18 P.M. Article 7 declared adopted.
10:19 p.m. Presented by Joseph Pato
ARTICLE 8: ESTABLISH AND APPROPRIATE TO AND FROM SPECIFIED
STABILIZATION FUNDS
MOTION:That this article be indefinitely postponed.
Jill Hai reported unanimous support of the Capital Expenditures Committee.
Following a voice vote,Article 8 Declared Unanimously Adopted.
10:22 p.m. Presented by Norman Cohen.
ARTICLE 9: AMEND FY2014 OPERATING AND ENTERPRISE BUDGETS
MOTION:That this article be indefinitely postponed.
Following a voice vote,Article 9 Declared Unanimously Adopted.
10:23 p.m. Presented by Michelle Ciccolo.
ARTICLE 10: AMEND ARTICLE 5 OF NOVEMBER 4,2013 SPECIAL TOWN
MEETING,RENOVATION TO COMMUNITY CENTER
MOTION: That the motion under Article 5 of the warrant for the November 4,2013
Special Town Meeting as amended under Article 3 of the March 24,2014 Special Town
Meeting be amended to read as follows:
That$6,720,000 be appropriated for design,engineering and remodeling,reconstructing
and making extraordinary repairs to buildings at 39 Marrett Road,and that to meet this
appropriation$892,682 be appropriated from the Historic Resources Reserve of the
Community Preservation Fund,$2,818,462 be appropriated from the Unbudgeted
Reserve of the Community Preservation Fund,$2,135,040 be appropriated from
Undesignated Fund Balance of the Community Preservation Fund,$422,816 be
appropriated from the General Fund Unreserved Fund Balance and that the Treasurer,
with the approval of the Board of Selectmen,is authorized to borrow$451,000 under
M.G.L. Chapter 44, Section 7(3A),as amended,or under M.G.L.Chapter 44B,as
amended,or any other enabling authority.
Ms. Ciccolo reported unanimous support of the Board of Selectmen and further reported on the
requested funding and Community Center project status.
Marilyn Fenollosa reported support of Community Preservation Committee on vote of 7 in
favor, 1 opposed.
David Kanter reported unanimous support of the Capital Expenditures Committee.
Glenn Parker reported unanimous support(7-0)of the Appropriation Committee.
June 16, 2014 Special Town Meeting, cont....
10:31 p.m. Michelle Ciccolo responded to questions on work to be completed,requested
funding,and Town Meeting appropriation. Facilities Director Patrick Goddard
explained the increase in requested funding from March 2014 to date,including
detailed design and scope of work.
10:33 p.m. Frank Smith,pr.3,questioned magnitude of increase from March 2014 to date.
Patrick Goddard explained increase encountered,from schematic to more detailed
design and sometimes experience cost increases with scope of work changes,etc.
Permanent Building Committee Chair Jonathan Himmel,pr.6,further explained cost changes,
with greater analysis of building exterior and repair needs,fire protection
complications from other authorized work,and design of new entryway.
10:39 p.m. Vote on Article 10
Yes I No Abstain
129 14 3
Article 10 Declared Adopted by more than required two-thirds,with 129 in favor,4 opposed.
10:40 p.m. Presented by Michelle Ciccolo
ARTICLE 11: AMEND ARTICLE 2 OF THE MARCH 24,2014 SPECIAL TOWN
MEETING,CARY MEMORIAL BUILDING UPGRADES
MOTION: That this article be indefinitely postponed.
Ms. Ciccolo reported favorable bids and recommendation for Indefinite Postponement by the
Board of Selectmen.
Jill Hai reported unanimous support of the Capital Expenditures Committee.
10:41 p.m. Following a voice vote,Article 11 Declared Unanimously Adopted.
10:42 presented by Peter Kelley
ARTICLE 12: APPROPRIATE FOR AUTHORIZED CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS
MOTION: That this article be indefinitely postponed.
Unanimous support of the Capital Expenditures Committee reported.
10:42 p.m. Following a voice vote,Article 12 Declared Unanimously Adopted
10:42 p.m. Selectman Deborah Manger moved the June 16,2014 Special Town Meeting be
dissolved. Declared Unanimously Adopted.
A True Copy.
Attest:
Donna M.Hooper,Town Clerk
Article 2:Amend Article 3: Land Article 4: Authorize Article 5: Article 6: Amend Article 7: Article 10: Motion to Call
SPECIAL TOWN MEETING Of JUNE 16 2014 Zoning Bylaw 430 Acquisition Off Easement on Land at School General Bylaws— Amend Bylaws: Amend Art.5 of Nov.4, the Question
Articles 8,9,11 and 12-Indefinitely Postponed by unanimous voice vote Concord Ave Concord Ave 430 Concord Ave Master Plan Contracts and Deeds Report Period-Town 2013 STM Renovation Article 2
Counsel's Annual Rpt Community Center
First Name Middle Last Name Precinct
Michael J. Barrett AL
Deborah J. Brown AL Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain
Michelle Ciccolo AL yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Norman P. Cohen AL yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Donna M. Hooper AL Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain Abstain
Jay R. Kaufman AL
Peter C.1. Kelley AL yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Deborah N. Mauger AL yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Joseph N. Pato AL yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Abstain
Joel A. Adler 1 yes No No yes yes yes yes Yes
Nancy M. Adler 1 yes No yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Dirk Armstrong 1 yes Abstain yes yes yes Yes
John C.1. Bartenstein 1 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Jean W. Cole 1 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Jonathan G. Cole 1 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Robert W. Cunha 1 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Colin R. Hamilton 1
Brian E. Heffernan 1 No yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
lang Jean 1 No yes yes No yes yes yes Yes
Janet M. Kern 1 No No yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Hongbin Lou 1
Eric Jay Michelson 1 yes yes yes yes Yes
Joseph S. Rancatore 1
John F. Rossi 1 yes No yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Barry E. Sampson 1 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Carol J. Sampson 1 No No No yes yes yes yes Yes
Mary Ann Stewart 1 yes yes yes yes yes yes yes Yes
Bella D. Tsvetkova 1 No yes yes yes yes yes yes
Albert P. Zabin 1
Judith L. Zabin 1
S.Bijan Afshartous 2 yes yes yes yes yes yes No Yes
Laurel Carpenter 2 Abstain Yes Yes No
Marian A.O. Cohen 2
Kathryn Mayes Fields 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Rita B. Goldberg 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Paul H. Lapointe 2
Peter B. Lee 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Susan Leigh London 2 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Karen R. Longeteig 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Michael McGuirk 2
Richard L. Neumeier 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Barry Orenstein 2 Yes No Yes Yes
Michael J. O'Sullivan 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Margaret Ouellette 2 Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ricki Pappo 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
James M. Shaw 2 Yes Yes
Kenneth J. Shine 2 No Yes Yes No Abstain Yes No Yes
Jonathan E. Suber 2 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Jennifer M. Vogelzang 2 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Betsey Weiss 2
James S. Wilson 2 Yes Yes
Samuel Berman 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Michael D. Bliss 3 Abstain Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Bonnie E. Brodner 3 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Dan H. Fenn 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Shirley Rauson Frawley 3 Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Michelle Goddard 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Steven P. Heinrich 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Nancy L. Hubert 3
Kevin Johnson 3
Kenneth M. Kreutziger 3
Jeanne K. Krieger 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Henry S. Lau 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Rosemary Donnis Levy 3
Beth J. Masterman 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sarah Nathan 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Judith L. Pappo 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Glenn P. Parker 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Cynthia Piltch 3 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Robert Rotberg 3 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Franklin E. Smith 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Margaret B. Storch 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Alessandro A. Alessandrini 4
Nyles Nathan Barnert 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Gloria J. Bloom 4 No No Yes Yes Yes No
Michael P. Boudett 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Scott F. Burson 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Robert N. Cohen 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Kathryn R. Colburn 4 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Thomas R. Diaz 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Peter David Enrich 4 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Jill I. Hai 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Laura J. Hussong 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Kathleen M. Lenihan 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ellen 10 McDonald 4 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Susan A. McLeish 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Paul Miniutti 4 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Molly Harding Nye 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
John M. Patrick 4 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Gerald Paul 4
Sandra J. Shaw 4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Nancy Ann Shepard 4 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ruth S. Thomas 4 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
David E. Burns 5
Nancy Corcoran-Ronchetti 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Jeffrey J. Crampton 5 Yes Yes
Judith A. Crocker 5
Irene M. Dondley 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Elaine Dratch 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Marilyn M. Fenollosa 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Andrew J. Friedlich 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Anthony G. Galaitsis 5 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
John Hayward 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ginna Johnson 5 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Taylor M. Lahiff 5
James R. Lowry 5
Pamela B. Lyons 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Jerold S. Michelson 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Sam Silverman 5 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Lisa L. Smith 5
Marc A. SaintLouis 5 No Yes Yes Yes Yes
M.Masha Traber 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ephraim Weiss 5 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
David G. Williams 5 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Suzanne D. Abair 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Osman Babson 6
Todd J. Cataldo 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Paul Chernick 6 No Yes
Margaret L. Counts-Klebe 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Bebe H. Fallick 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Edmund C. Grant 6
Jonathan A. Himmel 6 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Frederic S. Johnson 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Morton G. Kahan 6
David L. Kaufman 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Brian P. Kelley 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ann M. Kelly 6 Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Trisha P. Kennealy 6
Dawn E. McKenna 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Stephen W. McKenna 6
Jane Pagett 6 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Dinesh Patel 6 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Edith Sandy 6 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Frank Sandy 6 No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Deborah Strod 6 No No Yes Yes Yes
Marsha E. Baker 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Elizabeth DeMille Barnett 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Donald O. Benson 7
George A. Burnell 7 Yes Yes Yes Abstain Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mary Burnell 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Patricia Elen Costello 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
James W. Courtemanche 7
Catherine Woodward Gill 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Thomas V. Griffiths 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mary C. Hamilton 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Pam Hoffman 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes
David G. Kanter 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Raul Marques-Pascual 7 No Yes Yes Yes No
Fred H. Martin 7 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Joyce A. Miller 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Benjamin L. Moroze 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
John D. Pompeo 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Paul J. Rubin 7 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Elizabeth Anne Sarles 7 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Thomas J. Wanderer 7
Geoffrey G. Xiao 7
Robert M. Avallone S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Elizabeth Barrentine S No No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes
Larry N. Belvin S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Diane M. Biglow S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Margaret Bradley S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Gang Chen S No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Timothy Y. Dunn S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Abstain
Margaret S. Enders S
Charles Hornig S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Abstain Abstain
David C. Horton S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Stewart G. Kennedy 8 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ingrid H. Klimoff S Abstain Yes Yes Abstain
Alan Mayer Levine S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Richard A. Michelson S
James A. Osten S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Andrei Radulescu-Banu S No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes No
William A. Ribich S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Jessie Steigerwald S No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Shirley H. Stolz S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Melinda M. Walker S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Weidong Wang S Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Alice J. Adler 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Narain D. Bhatia 9 No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Victoria Lawrence Blier 9 Yes Abstain Yes Yes No
Jeanne P. Canale 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Richard L. Canale 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Helen L. Cohen 9
Rodney Cole 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Margaret E. Coppe 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Thomas O. Fenn 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mollie K. Garberg 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mark P. Maguire 9
Hank Manz 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Wendy Manz 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
John Mazerall 9
Lisa J. Mazerall 9
Leo P. McSweeney 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Christina M. Murray 9
Janet M. Perry 9
Lisah S. Rhodes 9 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Mark R. Vitunic 9 Yes No No No Yes Yes No Yes
Justine A. Wirtanen 9
Total =Yes 114 131 147 136 132 135 129 133
Total 2=No 38 18 4 3 1 4 18
Total Voters 152 149 151 139 133 135 133 151