HomeMy WebLinkAbout2013-10-10-CEC-minMinutes of the Lexington Capital Expenditures Committee (CEC) Meeting
October 10, 2013
Location and Time: Town Office Building, Reed Room (111); 10:00 A.M.
Members Present: Jill Hai, Chair; David Kanter, Vice - Chair; Beth Masterman;
Wendy Manz
Member Absent: Bill Hurley
Documents Presented:
• Draft Minutes for the September 24, 2013, CEC Meeting
• Draft Minutes for the October 3, 2013, CEC Meeting
• Draft Input on Article 4 for the CEC Report to the November 4, 2013, Special Town
Meeting ( "Fall STM "), prepared by Bill Hurley
• Town Warrant for the Fall STM
Call to Order: Ms. Hai called the meeting to order at 10:04 A.M.
CEC Report to the Fall STM: The Committee agreed to its responsibilities regarding the
Articles on the Town Warrant as follows:
• Article 1 (Reports of Town Boards, Officers, Committees): The Report will need to be
received and placed on file. Whether there is a need for any spoken comments to be
made when doing that is yet to be determined. Action assigned to the Chair.
• Article 2 (Amend FY2014 Operating, Enterprise Fund and Community Preservation
Budgets): Normally the Committee would only report on the Community Preservation
Budget and Mr. Addelson, Assistant Town Manager for Finance, advised Mr. Kanter
during their meeting this past Tuesday (the 8 that no changes are currently
contemplated for that budget. The fact that the Community Preservation Fund is
contemplated as at least the major, if not the total funding source for the work on the
Community Center under Article 5 is not expected to affect the Community
Preservation Budget. Remains assigned to Mr. Kanter if any changes to that budget
should be proposed.
• Article 3 (Appropriate to and from Specific Stabilization Funds): At that same
meeting, Mr. Addelson advised Mr. Kanter that there are actions contemplated at
least for the Capital Projects /Debt Service Reserve /Building Renewal Fund in
conjunction with the proposed funding— consistent with the Model IV endorsed by
the Committee at its September 24, 2013, meeting —of the modular classrooms at
the Lexington High School under Article 4. The Committee noted that at the
October 3, 2013, Budget Collaboration - Financial Summit 1 none of the other
participating entities objected to using the Model IV approach to that funding.
Mr. Addelson advised there may be minor accounting adjustments to one or more of
the other Stabilization Funds —only some of which have capital implications that
would deserve being addressed in this Committee's report. Remains assigned jointly
to Ms. Hai and Mr. Kanter.
• Article 4 (Appropriate for Modular Classrooms at the High School): Remains
assigned to Mr. Hurley.
Page 1 of 3
Minutes of the Lexington Capital Expenditures Committee (CEC) Meeting
October 10, 2013
• Article 5 (Appropriate for Renovations to Buildings to be Acquired at 39 Marrett
Road): Remains assigned to Ms. Masterman.
Mr. Kanter distributed Mr. Hurley's draft for Article 4. Ms. Masterman's questions about the
nature of the expected write -up on Article 5 were answered and she will shortly submit her
draft to Mr. Kanter. He, in turn, will distribute to all members a first draft, if not also
additional drafts, of the report for consideration by the Committee at its next meeting.
With regard to the Model IV approach for financing the Modular Classrooms at the High
School, Mr. Kanter had discussed with Mr. Addelson at their meeting that as it used the
mid -point cost within the then - identified estimated cost range for this project, this
Committee is looking forward to knowing the bottom -line cost in the later cost estimate that
is expected before the Fall STM.
Member Concerns and Liaison Reports:
Mr. Kanter reported that at the request of Deb Mauger (Chair of the Board of Selectmen
[BoS]), Jon Himmel (Co -Chair of the Permanent Building Committee), Glenn Parker (Chair
of the Appropriation Committee), and himself —all having followed what the Ad hoc
Community Center Advisory Committee (AhCCAC) is doing —met with her this past
Tuesday, along with Carl Valente (Town Manager), Pat Goddard (Director of Public
Facilities), and Michelle Ciccolo (Chair of the AhCCAC) to discuss the on -going process
leading to the request planned at the Fall STM under its Article 5 for the next funding
needed for the 1 s ' phase in creating a new Community Center. It was agreed that the
Charge to the AhCCAC was sufficient as currently written and that, with Ms. Ciccolo's
leadership, that committee was properly addressing programmatic issues; however,
Messrs. Himmel, Parker, and himself felt others in Town advisory positions also should be
looking, along with the Department of Public Facilities, at the project timing, engineering,
and costing aspects being prepared by Steffian Bradley Architects (SBA) —the Town's
contractor expected to address all of the project's 1 s ' phase design & engineering, and the
schematic design of its 2 nd phase. All at the meeting agreed that those aspects are neither
within the Charge of the AhCCAC nor was its membership chosen to have the expertise to
address those aspects. Of particular concern is whether the allocations for funding to cover
contingencies up to and including the construction of the 1 s ' phase scope are adequate.
Ms. Mauger and Mr. Valente agreed with having Mr. Goddard consider the discussion at
the meeting and the material provided by Messrs. Himmel, Parker, and himself as
Mr. Goddard works with SBA on their upcoming update to the cost estimate and timeline for
the project's 1 s ' phase.
Mr. Kanter also reported that the AhCCAC had made its recommendation to the BoS this
past Monday (the 7 that the Recreation Department staff be moved, as was the previous
recommendation regarding the Human Services Department staff, to the new Community
Center in the Phase 1, initial occupancy, in 2014. A factor in making that recommendation
was that the likely renovation of the Cary Memorial Building — perhaps starting in 2014 —
would eliminate an important, existing, Recreation Department storage location in that
Page 2 of 3
Minutes of the Lexington Capital Expenditures Committee (CEC) Meeting
October 10, 2013
building and the test fit done by SBA for the AhCCAC has shown that Department could
have the needed storage in the Community Center building. The Committee discussed that
the current Phase 1 scope doesn't include a commercial kitchen so that the Human
Services Department would likely have to use caterers for the Senior Center meals
program.
Approval of Minutes:
• It was moved and seconded to approve the Minutes for the September 24, 2013,
meeting, with editorial corrections to what was presented. Vote: 4 -0
• It was moved and seconded to approve the Minutes for the October 3, 2013,
meeting, as presented. Vote: 4-0
Next Meeting: It was agreed to add a meeting on October 16, 2013, to those already
planned with hope that between it and the meeting on October 21 S ', it will be possible to get
votes and approval from all five members of this Committee of the its report to the Fall
STM. The plan remains that the report would be published on October 28'" so as to meet
the goal of the report being available one week before the Town Meeting would have any
Motion presented for a matter on which this Committee first must report.
Adjourn: A Motion was made and seconded at 10:56 A.M. to adjourn. Vote: 4 -0
These Minutes were approved by the CEC at its meeting on October 16, 2013.
Page 3 of 3